CLM buying

Building the CFO Business Case for CLM in India: A Fill-In Cost Model and One-Page Memo

Adira EditorialLegal AI desk11 min read

Most requests for contract management software in Indian companies die in the same place: a CFO reads a vendor brochure forwarded by legal, sees a dollar price per seat, and asks what the company gets for it that it does not already get from email, shared drives and an Excel tracker. The request comes back with "let us revisit next quarter". The fix is not a better brochure. It is a short, numbers-first case built from your own contracts, priced with real arithmetic including tax, routed through the approval chain your company actually uses, and paired with a promise to measure. This page walks through each part, with a fill-in model you can copy. ## Start with what the current process costs, in rupees A CFO trusts a number they can trace. Every figure in the table below should come from your own records: the contract register (or the email search that substitutes for one), timesheets or a fair estimate of hours, and finance's view of what a delayed deal or a missed renewal costs. | Line | Your input | How to get it | |---|---|---| | A. Contracts reviewed or drafted per year | ____ | Count the last 12 months from email, the register or the e-stamp purchase log | | B. Average lawyer hours per contract | ____ | Time five recent contracts end to end, including back-and-forth | | C. Loaded cost per lawyer hour (Rs) | ____ | CTC plus overhead divided by working hours, or the outside counsel rate | | D. Review cost per year (A x B x C) | ____ | Arithmetic | | E. Contracts that auto-renewed or lapsed unnoticed last year | ____ | Ask finance and procurement for surprises | | F. Average cost of each such miss (Rs) | ____ | The renewal you would have renegotiated or the penalty paid | | G. Missed-date cost per year (E x F) | ____ | Arithmetic | | H. Days a sales contract waits for legal | ____ | Median from request to sign-off | | I. Cost of delay per contract-day (Rs) | ____ | Finance's estimate, or leave blank if contested | Line D is usually the most defensible. Lines G and I persuade, but only if finance agrees with the inputs. If finance disputes a line, drop it rather than argue; a smaller case that nobody challenges beats a larger case that gets picked apart. ### A filled-in example, so the model makes sense Take a hypothetical mid-sized Indian manufacturer with a three-person legal team. These are illustrative inputs, not benchmarks: - 360 contracts a year (A), averaging 4 hours each (B), at a loaded Rs 2,000 an hour (C). Review cost: 360 x 4 x 2,000 = Rs 28,80,000 a year.

  • Three vendor contracts auto-renewed on old rates last year (E), each costing an estimated Rs 1,50,000 more than a renegotiated rate would have (F). Missed-date cost: Rs 4,50,000.
  • Delay cost left blank because sales and finance could not agree on a figure. The status quo in this example costs roughly Rs 33 lakh a year in measurable terms. The question for the CFO then becomes: what share of that does the software remove, and what does it cost? The honest answer to the first part is "we will find out in a trial", which is why the trial design and 90-day measures matter more than any projection. ## The cost side: seat arithmetic with nothing hidden CLM pricing in India comes in two shapes: published per-seat prices, usually in US dollars, and quote-only enterprise pricing that needs a sales call. Where a price is published, show the arithmetic in the memo instead of a rounded figure. Using Adira's published plans as the worked example: | Plan | Price per seat per month | Minimum seats | Annual cost at the minimum | |---|---|---|---| | Practice, billed annually | USD 89 | 3 | 3 x 89 x 12 = USD 3,204 | | Practice, billed monthly | USD 109 | 3 | 3 x 109 x 12 = USD 3,924 | | Firm, billed annually | USD 179 | 5 | 5 x 179 x 12 = USD 10,740 | | Firm, billed monthly | USD 219 | 5 | 5 x 219 x 12 = USD 13,140 | Convert at the day's rate when you submit the memo, and say which rate you used. The FBIL USD/INR reference rate is a neutral choice that finance teams recognise. Add a line for exchange movement over the year if your treasury team normally does so for dollar-denominated subscriptions. For a quote-only vendor, ask for a written quote that states the seat count, the minimum term, what is charged as implementation, and the renewal uplift cap. A quote without a renewal cap is only a first-year price. ## GST: who pays it depends on where the vendor sits This is the line that most legal-led business cases miss and every CFO checks. If the vendor is located outside India and your company is GST-registered, the subscription is an import of services and the tax is paid by you under reverse charge. Entry 1 of Notification No. 10/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate) places IGST on any service supplied by a person in a non-taxable territory to any person in India other than a non-taxable online recipient, payable by the recipient. The CBIC sectoral FAQ for IT and ITeS puts the rate on IT services at 18% and answers the online database case directly: a registered recipient pays IGST on reverse charge. The same FAQ notes that reverse-charge tax must be paid in cash, not set off against existing credit (it cites Rule 85(4) of the CGST Rules), after which the credit can be claimed subject to the usual conditions. What that means for the memo: on a USD 10,740 subscription, the company pays the IGST in cash when the liability arises and recovers it as input tax credit later, so the budget shows a cash-flow timing cost rather than a permanent cost, provided the credit conditions are met. Your chartered accountant should confirm eligibility and also advise on any withholding question for the overseas payment. If the vendor is an Indian entity, even one quoting in dollars, it is a domestic supply. The vendor charges GST on its invoice and you take credit in the normal way. Adira is a product of Clausio LLP, an Indian limited liability partnership, so a buyer should ask Adira for the invoicing entity, its GSTIN and how the invoice will show tax before finalising the budget line rather than assuming reverse charge. ## The one-page memo, ready to fill CFOs in Indian companies read the first five lines and the numbers. Keep the memo to one page with this structure: 1. Ask. "Approve [plan] for [n] seats at [USD amount] a year (Rs [amount] at today's FBIL rate), plus GST as applicable, for a 12-month term."
  1. Problem in rupees. Line D and, if agreed, line G from the model.
  2. What changes. Three specific changes, for example: standard NDAs and vendor agreements drafted from house templates; counterparty drafts flagged for unfavourable terms before a lawyer reads them; every signed contract with renewal and notice dates on file.
  3. Evidence. The result of your own trial on your own contracts, with the sample size stated.
  4. Risks and controls. Data handling answers from the vendor in writing, exit and export terms, and who owns the tool internally.
  5. Measures and review date. The three numbers in the section below, with a review 90 days after go-live. Attach the cost model and the vendor's written security answers as annexures. Do not attach the brochure. ## Getting through the approval chain an Indian company actually has The software is often the easy part. The routing is where weeks go. - Delegation of authority. Check the financial limit at which approval moves from the CFO to the CEO or board committee. An annual prepay that crosses that limit can take longer than a monthly plan that stays under it.
  • Vendor onboarding. Procurement will want the vendor's PAN or foreign tax details, GST registration (or a reverse-charge note for an overseas vendor), bank details on letterhead, and possibly an MSME declaration. Ask the vendor for the set on day one.
  • IT and information security review. A data-handling questionnaire is common for any tool that stores contracts. Send it early, in parallel with the trial.
  • Payment route. Overseas subscriptions are often paid by corporate card or foreign remittance. Finance will want to know which, because it changes documentation and timing.
  • Budget head. Decide whether the cost sits under legal, IT or general administration. A cost that has no budget head waits for the next cycle. ## What to measure in the first 90 days Promise measures you can actually collect without building a reporting project: | Measure | Baseline (before go-live) | Day 90 | |---|---|---| | Median days from contract request to signature, standard agreements | ____ | ____ | | Lawyer hours per review on a sample of 10 counterparty drafts | ____ | ____ | | Signed contracts with renewal and notice dates recorded | ____ | ____ | | Renewals caught before the notice deadline | ____ | ____ | Take the baseline in the two weeks before go-live. A 90-day review that shows honest movement on two of these four is a stronger renewal argument than any projection. For the wider return question beyond the first quarter, see our page on contract management software ROI in India, and for the vendor shortlist that should precede this memo, see the CLM RFP checklist for India. ## Where Adira fits in the case, and where it does not Adira is an AI contract lifecycle tool built India-first, which matters for the "what changes" section: its document review flags positions as favourable, neutral or unfavourable to your company and surfaces Indian compliance items such as Companies Act points, Section 42 and PAS-3, SEBI, FEMA and stamp duty, alongside key dates, obligations and missing clauses. It drafts from your own documents through a company persona and supports e-signing and e-stamping in the same workspace. For evidence, the only figures to cite are Adira's own measured results, presented as such: 18 law firms use Adira, and across those deployments contract review and due diligence that took 10 to 12 days manually came down to under 2 hours, with only 2 to 3 rechecks needed. Those are law-firm results, so a corporate legal team should treat them as a reason to test, not as a forecast for its own numbers. The 7-day free trial is short, so plan it with real contracts and the baseline already taken. Limits worth stating in the memo: SSO/SAML, audit logs, and data residency and retention controls sit on the Enterprise plan, so a company whose IT policy requires them should price Enterprise, which is quoted on request. Adira is also not an ERP or procurement system, so purchase orders and vendor master data stay where they are today. ## Three objections finance raises, with straight answers "We already pay for Microsoft 365 and a drive. Why another tool?" Storage is not the gap. The gap is that nobody can answer "which contracts renew next quarter and on what notice?" without opening files one by one. Show the CFO the last renewal that slipped through and ask how the current setup would have caught it. "The lawyers will not use it." A fair worry, and the reason to name one internal owner and to measure usage at day 30, not day 90. If fewer than the seats you bought are active after a month, cut seats at renewal rather than defend them. "Can we not just use a general AI chatbot?" Some teams do for one-off questions. The business case for CLM rests on things a chat window does not keep: a contract record, version history, dates that trigger reminders, and controls on who saw what. Put that difference in one sentence in the memo. ## A short checklist before you send the memo - Cost model filled from your own records, with disputed lines removed
  • Seat arithmetic shown, currency rate and date stated
  • GST treatment confirmed with your CA for the vendor's actual location
  • Approval limit checked against annual versus monthly billing
  • Vendor onboarding documents requested
  • Security answers received in writing
  • Three baseline measures taken
  • Review date set 90 days after go-live

Frequently asked questions

Do we pay GST on a CLM subscription bought from a vendor outside India?
If your company is GST-registered and the vendor is located outside India, the import of the service is taxed under reverse charge: your company pays IGST itself under Notification 10/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate), entry 1. The CBIC sectoral FAQ says reverse-charge tax is paid in cash, and the credit can then be claimed subject to the usual conditions. Confirm the position for your facts with your chartered accountant.
What if the CLM vendor is an Indian entity billing in US dollars?
Then it is a domestic supply, not an import. The vendor charges GST on its invoice if it is registered, and you claim input tax credit in the normal way. Ask the vendor which entity will invoice, its GSTIN and the place of supply before you finalise the budget line.
Should the business case use industry ROI figures?
Avoid them. A CFO will ask where the number came from, and most published figures come from vendors and do not match your contract mix. A model built from your own contract counts, hours and delay costs is smaller but survives questioning.
Is annual or monthly billing better for a first CLM purchase in India?
Annual is cheaper per seat but commits the money upfront, which can trigger a higher approval tier. Monthly costs more but keeps the first commitment small. Many teams run the trial, buy monthly for one quarter to prove usage, then switch to annual with evidence in hand.
What should the business case promise to measure in the first 90 days?
Pick three numbers you can measure without new systems: turnaround time for a standard contract from request to signature, the count of contracts with a known renewal date on file, and hours of lawyer time per review on a sampled set. Measure them before go-live so the 90-day review compares like with like.
Was this useful?

See how Adira drafts in your voice and reads contracts from your side.

Explore the showroom

Working through a contract like this? Weave is Adira’s free tool to read, mark up, and connect any contract in your browser — no account needed.

Try Weave — free

Book a demo

See Adira on your own contracts

A 30-minute walkthrough with our team. Tell us a little about you, then pick a time that suits you.

Prefer email? [email protected]